我们的网站为什么显示成这样？

可能因为您的浏览器不支持样式，您可以更新您的浏览器到最新版本，以获取对此功能的支持，访问下面的网站，获取关于浏览器的信息：

|本期目录/Table of Contents|

 奖惩机制对两难困境中合作行为的影响模式及其差异(PDF)

《心理学探新》[ISSN:1003-5184/CN:36-1228/B]

期数:
 2025年02期
页码:
 143-152
栏目:
 
出版日期:
 2025-04-20

文章信息/Info

Title:
 The Patterns and Differences of the Effects of Rewards and Punishments in Social Dilemma Cooperation
文章编号:
1003-5184(2025)02-0143-10
作者:
 周靖昆; 崔丽莹
 (上海师范大学心理学院,上海 200234)
Author(s):
 Zhou Jingkun;  Cui Liying
 (School of Psychology,Shanghai Normal University,Shanghai 200234)
关键词:
 奖励;  惩罚;  合作;  社会困境;  边界
Keywords:
 reward;  punishment;  cooperation;  social dilemma;  boundaries
分类号:
 B848
DOI:
 -
文献标识码:
 A
摘要:
 作为一种重要的激励机制,奖惩机制是通过奖励合作者和惩罚搭便车者促进社会困境中的合作,但二者对合作的影响过程或模式存在差异。一方面,奖惩机制对合作的影响存在效果差异,奖惩机制如何发挥出最优效果会受到不同奖惩环境的影响; 另一方面,奖惩机制对合作的影响存在过程差异,奖惩机制会通过诱发互惠机制、情绪机制、行为机制、生理机制来促进合作; 同时奖惩机制也会通过诱发资源损耗、认知损耗、行为损耗来破坏合作。未来研究可以扩展考察奖惩对更多类型或情境下合作行为的影响,增加研究结论的生态效度,进一步厘清奖惩对合作影响的最优力度与团体规模,有效识别和确定奖惩机制在促进与破坏合作之间的边界。
Abstract:
 As an important incentive mechanism,although rewarding cooperators and punishing free riders both can promote cooperation in social dilemmas,they have difference in the modes and processes on cooperation.On the one hand,the effect of reward and punishment mechanism on cooperation is different,and the optimal effect of reward and punishment mechanism is affected by different reward and punishment environment.On the other hand,there are process differences in the influence of reward and punishment mechanism on cooperation.Reward and punishment mechanism can promote cooperation by inducing reciprocal mechanisms,emotional mechanisms,behavioral mechanisms,physiological mechanisms.At the same time,the reward and punishment mechanism will also destroy cooperation by inducing resource loss,cognitive loss and behavioral loss.In the future,the research can expand the impact of rewards and punishments on cooperative behavior in more types or situations,and increase the ecological validity of research conclusions,clarify the optimal intensity and group size of rewards and punishments on cooperation,and effectively identify and determine the boundaries between reward and punishment mechanisms in promoting and undermining cooperation.

参考文献/References

 陈璟,张融,袁佳琦,佘升翔.(2022).博弈中的反社会惩罚.心理科学进展,30(2),436-448.
陈思静,何铨,马剑虹.(2015).第三方惩罚对合作行为的影响:基于社会规范激活的解释.心理学报,47(3),389-405.
陈思静,邢懿琳,翁异静,黎常.(2021).第三方惩罚对合作的溢出效应:基于社会规范的解释.心理学报,53(7),758-772.
陈欣,赵国祥,叶浩生.(2014).公共物品困境中惩罚的形式与作用.心理科学进展,22(1),160-170.
崔丽莹,何幸,罗俊龙,黄晓娇,曹玮佳,陈晓梅.(2017).道德与关系惩罚对初中生公共物品困境中合作行为的影响.心理学报,49(10),1322-1333.
郝娜,崔丽莹.(2022).补偿他人还是保护自己?内疚与羞耻情绪对合作行为的影响差异.心理科学进展,30(7),1626-1636.
孔程程,王晓明.(2018).惩罚对合作的影响:形式、机制及边界条件.心理研究,11(2),166-172.
李晶,朱莉琪.(2014).高功能孤独症儿童的合作行为.心理学报,46(9),1301-1316.
任海霞,黄瑶,郝娜,崔丽莹.(2021).特质感恩与状态感恩对初中生合作水平的影响.心理科学,44(1),97-103.
王沛,陈莉.(2011).惩罚和社会价值取向对公共物品两难中人际信任与合作行为的影响.心理学报,43(1),52-64.
张大俭.(2016).奖励与惩罚的心理机制及在学校教育中的有效运用.沧州师范学院学报,32(1),80-83.
Attaran,A.,Salahinejad,A.,Crane,A.L.,Niyogi,S.,& Chivers,D.P.(2019).Chronic exposure to dietary selenomethionine dysregulates the genes involved in serotonergic neurotransmission and alters social and antipredator behaviours in zebrafish(Danio rerio).Environmental Pollution,246,837-844.
Baik,J.-H.(2020).Stress and the dopaminergic reward system.Experimental & Molecular Medicine,52(12),1879-1890.
Balafoutas,L.N.,& Rockenbach,B.(2014).Direct and indirect punishment among strangers in the field.Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences,111(45),15924-15927.
Balcombe,K.,Bardsley,N.,Dadzie,S.,& Fraser,I.(2019).Estimating parametric loss aversion with prospect theory:Recognising and dealing with size dependence.Journal of Economic Behavior & Organization,162,106-119.
Balliet,D.,Mulder,L.B.,& Van Lange,P.A.M.(2011).Reward,punishment,and cooperation:A meta-analysis.Psychological Bulletin,137(4),594-615.
Balliet,D.,& Van Lange,P.A.M.(2013a).Trust,conflict,and cooperation:A meta-analysis.Psychological Bulletin,139(5),1090-1112.
Balliet,D.,& Van Lange,P.A.M.(2013b).Trust,Punishment,and Cooperation Across 18 Societies:A Meta-Analysis.Perspectives on Psychological Science,8(4),363-379.
Barrós-Loscertales,A.,Meseguer,V.,Sanjuán,A.,Belloch,V.,Parcet,M.A.,Torrubia,R.,& ?vila,C.(2006).Behavioral Inhibition System activity is associated with increased amygdala and hippocampal gray matter volume:A voxel-based morphometry study.NeuroImage,33(3),1011-1015.
Bénabou,R.,& Tirole,J.(2006).Incentives and Prosocial Behavior.American Economic Review,96(5),1652-1678.
Barcelo,H.,& Capraro,V.(2015).Group size effect on cooperation in one-shot social dilemmas.Scientific Reports,5,7937.
Bradley,E.R.,Brustkern,J.,Coster,L.D.,Bos,W.,McClure,S.M.,Seitz,A.,& Woolley,J.D.(2020).Victory is its own reward:Oxytocin increases costly competitive behavior in schizophrenia.Psychological Medicine,50(4),674-682.
Bruhin,A.,Janizzi,K.,& Th?ni,C.(2020).Uncovering the heterogeneity behind cross-cultural variation in antisocial punishment.Journal of Economic Behavior & Organization,180,291-308.
Buskens,V.,Corten,R.,& Snijders,C.(Eds).(2020). Advances in the Sociology of Trust and Cooperation:Theory,Experiments,and Field Studies.De Gruyter.
Bartlett,M.Y.,Condon,P.,Cruz,J.,Baumann,J.,& Desteno,D.(2012).Gratitude:Prompting behaviours that build relationships.Cognition & Emotion,26(1),2-13.
Balconi,M.,& Fronda,G.(2021).Gratitude Affects Inter-Subjective Synchronicity for Cognitive Performance and Autonomic Responsiveness.Frontiers in Psychology,12,574983.
Chao,M.(2017).Demotivating incentives and motivation crowding out in charitable giving.Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences,114(28),7301-7306.
Cressman,R.,Wu,J.-J.,Li,C.,& Tao,Y.(2013).Game Experiments on Cooperation Through Reward and Punishment.Biological Theory,8(2),158-166.
Chen,X.,Sasaki,T.,Br?nnstr?m,?.,& Dieckmann,U.(2015).First carrot,then stick:How the adaptive hybridization of incentives promotes cooperation. Journal of The Royal Society Interface,12,20140935.
Daw,N.D.,Kakade,S.,& Dayan,P.(2002).Opponent interactions between serotonin and dopamine.Neural Networks,15,603-616.
Dong,Y.,Sasaki,T.,& Zhang,B.(2019).The competitive advantage of institutional reward. Proceedings of the Royal Society B:Biological Sciences,286,20190001.
dos Santos,M.(2015).The evolution of anti-social rewarding and its countermeasures in public goods games.Proceedings of the Royal Society B:Biological Sciences,282,20141994.
dos Santos,M.,& Pe?a,J.(2017).Antisocial rewarding in structured populations.Scientific Reports,7,6212.
Du,C.,Jia,D.,Jin,L.,& Shi,L.(2018).The impact of neutral reward on cooperation in public good game.The European Physical Journal B,91,234.
Dari-Mattiacci,G.,& Geest,G.D.(2009).Carrots,Sticks,and the Multiplication Effect.The Journal of Law,Economics,and Organization,26(2),365-384.
DeSteno,D.,Bartlett,M.Y.,Baumann,J.,Williams,L.A.,& Dickens,L.(2010).Gratitude as moral sentiment:Emotion-guided cooperation in economic exchange.Emotion,10(2),289-293.
Fang,Y.,Benko,T.P.,Perc,M.,Xu,H.,& Tan,Q.(2019).Synergistic third-party rewarding and punishment in the public goods game.Proceedings of the Royal Society A:Mathematical,Physical and Engineering Sciences,475,20190349.
Fang,Y.,Perc,M.,& Xu,H.(2020).The Singaporean model in public goods dilemmas with benevolent leaders and bribery.Journal of Theoretical Biology,501,110345.
Fehr,E.,& Gachter,S.(2000).Fairness and Retaliation:The Economics of Reciprocity.American Economic Review,14(3),159-181.
Flores,L.S.,Fernandes,H.C.M.,Amaral,M.A.,& Vainstein,M.H.(2021).Symbiotic behaviour in the public goods game with altruistic punishment. Journal of Theoretical Biology,524,110737.
Friedman,D.,& Singh,N.(2004).Negative reciprocity:The coevolution of memes and genes.Evolution and Human Behavior,25(3),155-173.
G?chter,S.,Renner,E.,& Sefton,M.(2008).The Long-Run Benefits of Punishment.Science,322,1510.
Gneezy,U.,Meier,S.,& Rey-Biel,P.(2011).When and Why Incentives(Don’t)Work to Modify Behavior.Journal of Economic Perspectives,25(4),191-210.
Greenwood,G.W.,Abbass,H.A.,& Petraki,E.(2018).When is altruistic punishment useful in social dilemmas?Biosystems,174,60-62.
Güth,W.,K?nigstein,M.,Marchand,N.,& Nehring,K.(2000).Trust and Reciprocity in the Investment Game with Indirect Reward.SFB 373 Discussion Paper,No.2000,110,Humboldt University of Berlin.
Hahn,T.,Dresler,T.,Plichta,M.M.,Ehlis,A.-C.,Ernst,L.H.,Markulin,F.,Polak,T.,Blaimer,M.,Deckert,J.,Lesch,K.-P.,Jakob,P.M.,& Fallgatter,A.J.(2010).Functional Amygdala-Hippocampus Connectivity During Anticipation of Aversive Events is Associated with Gray’s Trait “Sensitivity to Punishment”.Biological Psychiatry,68(5),459-464.
Hauert,C.(2010).Replicator dynamics of reward & reputation in public goods games.Journal of Theoretical Biology,267(1),22-28.
Heffner,J.,& FeldmanHall,O.(2019).Why we don’t always punish:Preferences for non-punitive responses to moral violations.Scientific Reports,9,13219.
Heine,F.,& Strobel,M.(2020).Reward and punishment in a team contest.PLOS ONE,15(9),e0236544.
Helbing,D.,Szolnoki,A.,Perc,M.,& Szabó,G.(2010).Punish,but not too hard:How costly punishment spreads in the spatial public goods game.New Journal of Physics,12(8),083005.
Henrich,J.,& Henrich,N.(2006).Culture,evolution and the puzzle of human cooperation.Cognitive Systems Research,7,220-245.
Herrmann,B.,Th?ni,C.,& G?chter,S.(2008).Antisocial Punishment Across Societies.Science,319,1362-1367.
Harth,N.S.,& Regner,T.(2017).The spiral of distrust:(Non-)cooperation in a repeated trust game is predicted by anger and individual differences in negative reciprocity orientation.International Journal of Psychology,52,18-25.
Hilbe,C.,& Sigmund,K.(2010).Incentives and opportunism:From the carrot to the stick.Proceedings of the Royal Society B:Biological Sciences,277,2427-2433.
Hu,L.,He,N.,Weng,Q.,Chen,X.,& Perc,M.(2020).Rewarding endowments lead to a win-win in the evolution of public cooperation and the accumulation of common resources.Chaos,Solitons & Fractals,134,109694.
Irwin,K.,Mulder,L.,& Simpson,B.(2014).The Detrimental Effects of Sanctions on Intragroup Trust:Comparing Punishments and Rewards.Social Psychology Quarterly,77(3),253-272.
Isoni,A.,& Sugden,R.(2019).Reciprocity and the Paradox of Trust in psychological game theory.Journal of Economic Behavior & Organization,167,219-227.
Jean-Richard-Dit-Bressel,P.,& McNally,G.P.(2015).The role of the basolateral amygdala in punishment.Learning & Memory,22(2),128-137.
Jacquet,J.,Hauert,C.,Traulsen,A.,& Milinski,M.(2012).Could shame and honor save cooperation?Communicative & Integrative Biology,5(2),209-213.
Karns,C.M.,Moore,W.E.,& Mayr,U.(2017).The Cultivation of Pure Altruism via Gratitude:A Functional MRI Study of Change with Gratitude Practice.Frontiers in Human Neuroscience,11,599.
Kitakaji,Y.,& Ohnuma,S.(2019).The Detrimental Effects of Punishment and Reward on Cooperation in the Industrial Waste Illegal Dumping Game.Simulation & Gaming,50(5),509-531.
Kiyonari,T.,& Barclay,P.(2008).Cooperation in social dilemmas:Free riding may be thwarted by second-order reward rather than by punishment.Journal of Personality and Social Psychology,95(4),826-842.
Lee,M.R.,Glassman,M.,King-Casas,B.,Kelly,D.L.,Stein,E.A.,Schroeder,J.,& Salmeron,B.J.(2014).Complexity of oxytocin’s effects in a chronic cocaine dependent population.European Neuropsychopharmacology,24(9),1483-1491.
Li,J.,Zhu,L.,& Chen,Z.(2018).The association between punishment and cooperation in children with high-functioning autism.Journal of Experimental Child Psychology,171,1-13.
Li,X.,Jusup,M.,Wang,Z.,Li,H.,Shi,L.,Podobnik,B.,Stanley,H.E.,Havlin,S.,& Boccaletti,S.(2018).Punishment diminishes the benefits of network reciprocity in social dilemma experiments.Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences,115(1),30-35.
Li,Y.,Chen,S.,& Niu,B.(2018).Reward depending on public funds stimulates cooperation in spatial prisoner’s dilemma games.Chaos,Solitons & Fractals,114,38-45.
Li,Y.,Zhong,W.,Wang,D.,Feng,Q.,Liu,Z.,Zhou,J.,Jia,C.,Hu,F.,Zeng,J.,Guo,Q.,Fu,L.,& Luo,M.(2016).Serotonin neurons in the dorsal raphe nucleus encode reward signals.Nature Communications,7,10503.
Liu,J.,Li,M.,Alam,M.,Chen,Y.,& Wu,T.(2019).A Game Theoretic Reward and Punishment Unwanted Traffic Control Mechanism.Mobile Networks and Applications,24(4),1279-1294.
Long,H.,Gong,R.,& Yao,J.(2022).Heterogeneous investments induced by emotions promote cooperation in public goods games.Europhysics Letters,137(2),21001.
McCullough,M.E.,Kilpatrick,S.D.,Emmons,R.A.,& Larson,D.B.(2001).Is gratitude a moral affect?Psychological Bulletin,127(2),249-266.
Molenmaker,W.E.,de Kwaadsteniet,E.W.,& van Dijk,E.(2016).The impact of personal responsibility on the(un)willingness to punish non-cooperation and reward cooperation.Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes,134,1-15.
Molho,C.,Tybur,J.M.,Van Lange,P.A.M.,& Balliet,D.(2020).Direct and indirect punishment of norm violations in daily life.Nature Communications,11,3432.
Mulder,L.B.(2008).The difference between punishments and rewards in fostering moral concerns in social decision making.Journal of Experimental Social Psychology,44(6),1436-1443.
Mulder,L.B.,van Dijk,E.,De Cremer,D.,& Wilke,H.A.M.(2006).Undermining trust and cooperation:The paradox of sanctioning systems in social dilemmas.Journal of Experimental Social Psychology,42(2),147-162.
Nagai,Y.,Takayama,K.,Nishitani,N.,Andoh,C.,Koda,M.,Shirakawa,H.,Nakagawa,T.,Nagayasu,K.,Yamanaka,A.,& Kaneko,S.(2020).The Role of Dorsal Raphe Serotonin Neurons in the Balance between Reward and Aversion.International Journal of Molecular Sciences,21(6),2160.
Nawijn,L.,van Zuiden,M.,Koch,S.B.J.,Frijling,J.L.,Veltman,D.J.,& Olff,M.(2016).Intranasal oxytocin enhances neural processing of monetary reward and loss in post-traumatic stress disorder and traumatized controls.Psychoneuroendocrinology,66,228-237.
Newman,G.E.,& Jeremy Shen,Y.(2012).The counterintuitive effects of thank-you gifts on charitable giving.Journal of Economic Psychology,33(5),973-983.
Nosenzo,D.,Quercia,S.,& Sefton,M.(2015).Cooperation in small groups:The effect of group size.Experimental Economics,18,4-14.
Noussair,C.N.,van Soest,D.,& Stoop,J.(2015).Punishment,reward,and cooperation in a framed field experiment.Social Choice and Welfare,45(3),537-559.
Nunney,S.J.,Schalk,J.,& Manstead,A.S.R.(2022).Emotion and intergroup cooperation:How verbal expressions of guilt,shame,and pride influence behavior in a social dilemma.Journal of Behavioral Decision Making,35(4),e2273.
Orsini,C.A.,Trotta,R.T.,Bizon,J.L.,& Setlow,B.(2015).Dissociable Roles for the Basolateral Amygdala and Orbitofrontal Cortex in Decision-Making under Risk of Punishment.Journal of Neuroscience,35(4),1368-1379.
Ozono,H.,Kamijo,Y.,& Shimizu,K.(2017).Punishing second-order free riders before first-order free riders:The effect of pool punishment priority on cooperation.Scientific Reports,7,14379.
Paula,J.R.,Messias,J.P.,Grutter,A.S.,Bshary,R.,& Soares,M.C.(2015).The role of serotonin in the modulation of cooperative behavior.Behavioral Ecology,26(4),1005-1012.
Pedersen,E.J.,McAuliffe,W.H.B.,Shah,Y.,Tanaka,H.,Ohtsubo,Y.,& McCullough,M.E.(2020).When and Why Do Third Parties Punish Outside of the Lab?A Cross-Cultural Recall Study.Social Psychological and Personality Science,11(6),846-853.
Pei,H.,Yan,G.,& Wang,H.(2021).Reciprocal rewards promote the evolution of cooperation in spatial prisoner’s dilemma game.Physics Letters A,390,127108.
Pimentel,A.F.N.,Carvalho,T.dos S.,Lima,F.,Lima-Maximino,M.,Soares,M.C.,& Maximino,C.(2019).Conditional approach as cooperation in predator inspection:A role for serotonin?Behavioural Brain Research,365,164-169.
Rai,A.,Ghosh,P.,Chauhan,R.,& Singh,R.(2018).Improving in-role and extra-role performances with rewards and recognition:Does engagement mediate the process?Management Research Review,41(8),902-919.
Raihani,N.J.,& Bshary,R.(2019).Punishment:One tool,many uses.Evolutionary Human Sciences,1,1-26.
Rand,D.G.,Armao IV,J.J.,Nakamaru,M.,& Ohtsuki,H.(2010).Anti-social punishment can prevent the co-evolution of punishment and cooperation.Journal of Theoretical Biology,265(4),624-632.
Rand,D.G.,Dreber,A.,Ellingsen,T.,Fudenberg,D.,& Nowak,M.A.(2009).Positive Interactions Promote Public Cooperation.Science,325,1272-1275.
Rankin,D.J.,Bargum,K.,& Kokko,H.(2007).The tragedy of the commons in evolutionary biology.Trends in Ecology & Evolution,22(12),643-651.
Rolls,E.T.(2019).The cingulate cortex and limbic systems for emotion,action,and memory.Brain Structure and Function,224(9),3001-3018.
Salazar,M.,Joel Shaw,D.,Czekóová,K.,Staněk,R.,& Brázdil,M.(2022).The role of generalised reciprocity and reciprocal tendencies in the emergence of cooperative group norms.Journal of Economic Psychology,90,102520.
Sefton,M.,Shupp,R.,& Walker,J.M.(2007).The effect of rewards and sanctions in provision of public goods.Economic Inquiry,45(4),671-690.
Shiraki,Y.,& Igarashi,T.(2018).“Paying it forward” via satisfying a basic human need:The need for relatedness satisfaction mediates gratitude and prosocial behavior.Asian Journal of Social Psychology,21(1-2),107-113.
Stuewig,J.,Tangney,J.P.,Kendall,S.,Folk,J.B.,Meyer,C.R.,& Dearing,R.L.(2015).Children’s Proneness to Shame and Guilt Predict Risky and Illegal Behaviors in Young Adulthood. Child Psychiatry & Human Development,46(2),217-227.
Strimling,P.,& Eriksson,K.(2014).Regulating the regulation:Norms about punishment.In P.A.M.Van Lange,B.Rockenbach,& T.Yamagishi(Eds.),Reward and punishment in social dilemmas(pp.52-69).New York,NY:Oxford.
Tangney,J.P.,Stuewig,J.,& Mashek,D.J.(2007).Moral Emotions and Moral Behavior.Annual Review of Psychology,58,345-372.
Ule,A.,Schram,A.,Riedl,A.,& Cason,T.N.(2009).Indirect Punishment and Generosity Toward Strangers.Science,326,1701-1704.
van den Berg,P.,Dewitte,P.,Aertgeerts,I.,& Wenseleers,T.(2020).How the incentive to contribute affects contributions in the one-shot public goods game.Scientific Reports,10,18732.
Wang,L.,& Murnighan,J.K.(2017).The dynamics of punishment and trust.Journal of Applied Psychology,102(10),1385-1402.
Wang,S.,Chen,X.,& Szolnoki,A.(2019).Exploring optimal institutional incentives for public cooperation.Communications in Nonlinear Science and Numerical Simulation,79,104914.
Wheelan,S.A.(2009).Group Size,Group Development,and Group Productivity.Small Group Research,40(2),247-262.
Wu,J.,Balliet,D.,Peperkoorn,L.S.,Romano,A.,& Van Lange,P.A.M.(2020).Cooperation in Groups of Different Sizes:The Effects of Punishment and Reputation-Based Partner Choice.Frontiers in Psychology,10,2956.
Wu,J.,Luan,S.,& Raihani,N.(2022).Reward,punishment,and prosocial behavior:Recent developments and implications.Current Opinion in Psychology,44,117-123.
Wu,J.J.,Zhang,B.Y.,Zhou,Z.X.,He,Q.Q.,Zheng,X.D.,Cressman,R.,& Tao,Y.(2009).Costly punishment does not always increase cooperation.Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America.punishment does not always increase cooperation.Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences,106(41),17448-17451.
Wu,Y.,Chang,S.,Zhang,Z.,& Deng,Z.(2017).Impact of Social Reward on the Evolution of the Cooperation Behavior in Complex Networks.Scientific Reports,7,41076.
Wu,Y.,Zhang,Z.,& Chang,S.(2019).Reciprocal reward promotes the evolution of cooperation in structured populations.Chaos,Solitons & Fractals,119,230-236.
Yang,C.-L.,Zhang,B.,Charness,G.,Li,C.,& Lien,J.W.(2018).Endogenous rewards promote cooperation.Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences,115(40),9968-9973.
Ye,H.,Chen,S.,Luo,J.,Tan,F.,Jia,Y.,& Chen,Y.(2016).Increasing returns to scale:The solution to the second-order social dilemma.Scientific Reports,6,31927.
Yu,L.,Chen,C.,Niu,Z.,Gao,Y.,Yang,H.,& Xue,Z.(2021).Risk aversion,cooperative membership and the adoption of green control techniques:Evidence from China.Journal of Cleaner Production,279,123288.
Zelmer,J.(2003).Linear Public Goods Experiments:A Meta-Analysis.Experimental Economics,6(3),299-310.
Zhang,B.,An,X.,& Dong,Y.(2021).Conditional cooperator enhances institutional punishment in public goods game.Applied Mathematics and Computation,390,125600.
Zhang,Z.,Song,F.,& Song,Z.(2020).Promoting knowledge sharing in the workplace:Punishment v.reward.Chaos,Solitons & Fractals,131,109518.

备注/Memo

备注/Memo:
 通信作者:崔丽莹,E-mail:cui720926@163.com。
更新日期/Last Update:  2025-04-30